Friday, November 6, 2015

Our Next President

     In every country that holds free elections, the president is elected based on a "popularity" contest!  Typically, the voters choose the candidate that appeals to them most, personally.  Every candidate promises a better life for all, better income, better health care, whatever else that the particular country needs to improve.  It is only natural for most voters to think in terms of "what's in it for me? What can you do for me?"  If the particular candidate appears to offer solutions to the voters' problems, be they financial or otherwise, then that candidate will receive the votes.  It is pretty straight forward.  Of course there are those who are more concerned with the overall welfare of the country and vote on those grounds, but by and large, personal needs trump everything else.
     It is unfortunate that political issues, particularly of international affairs, take a back seat to personal needs.  It is said by some that the American public is the most politically knowledgeable, educated voting public in the world.  Whoever said that did not check America's voting records!  Despite the modern age of easy travel and the current instant communication and electronic information availability, we Americans fall far behind Europeans and even some Asian countries in political knowledge and sophistication.  As it is with everyone in the world, what is most important to the average American voter is, what can a particular candidate do for them?
     There are millions of people in America that literally live hand to mouth, work for minimum wage and can barely put food on the table and make rent.  Of course, that is still far better than what millions of others in the world face daily.  Everything is relative.  America's minimum wage is good pay in many countries!  Nevertheless, it is understandable that someone living under such circumstances would be most concerned about their welfare, rather than some political issue or world situation. 
     If you promise to put two chickens in the pot and pay the rent, they will vote for you!  Promising them that you will defeat the enemy in some far away land like Afghanistan, Iraq or Syria, will not generate the same kind of enthusiasm.  Let's face it, the primary opposition to illegal aliens in this country is because of economic reasons, the perception that illegals are taking away jobs from Americans!  Sure, illegals commit murder and other crimes, but the main reason is that they are thought to be taking jobs away from Americans.  So, everything is tied to economic well being, a citizen's ability to earn money, put food on the table, buy a house, and yes, buy a better car!  We are a car driven society, no pun intended!  In another, less affluent society, a bicycle will replace the car!
     As I said, all of this is completely understandable and quite natural.  It is, after all, human instinct to survive, to get food, to improve living conditions.  However, in today's world, things aren't quite as simple as that.  Everything is tied to something else in one way or another.  Without political stability there is no opportunity to improve life, to better the standard of living, etc.  Political stability, unfortunately, comes with a price and certain sacrifices. A country must be prepared to make concession to rivals/enemies (which is not a good idea), or defeat rivals/enemies in war - economic or military.  Lately we seem to be making more concessions than anything else! 
     To accomplish the goal of stability, you need a strong leader in today's world.  You can't have a leader that is too wrapped up in political maneuvering and deal making.  Diplomatic solutions may work and in fact may be the best solution at times, but a leader should be one who is willing to make that difficult decision to go to war, even if it costs politically.  In other words, in these times, what America needs is a "Commander in Chief," someone who is willing to command the military in time of need without concern for political consequences.  However, Americans have largely become anti war and have no stomach for any war.  Naively, many think that with today's advanced technology, wars can be fought with drones and other high tech equipment, so when soldiers do die in battle, they immediately want to stop the war.   As a population, Americans have been anti war since Vietnam era.  So, it is very difficult for any president to go to war, to convince the population that war is the only solution to a particular problem.  Because of that, we need a very strong president, a true Commander in Chief who is more concerned in winning the war to secure future peace than his or her own political life!
     Since World War Two, America has had only a few true Commanders in Chief.  The first one was Eisenhower.  Although Eisenhower was much maligned and misunderstood by the media, he was one of the strongest post war presidents that we have had.  Kennedy was in the office for too short a period to really make a difference, but he did show some signs of being a strong leader.  Everyone else from that point on were not that good as Commanders in Chief except for Reagan and the first Bush didn't do too badly either.  Clinton was nothing but a pure politicians, that's why he was able to survive all those scandals! George W. tried mightily, but failed because he had advisors with personal agendas.  The current president is perhaps the weakest of all in that regard.  He may have accomplished some things on the domestic scene, thereby satisfying some of his voters, but he has been a miserable failure on international affairs and lacks the ability to be the true Commander in Chief as he has shown repeatedly.
     Whoever becomes our next president, Republican or Democrat, let us hope that he or she will be of sterner stuff that will make a strong Commander in Chief, not a politician!  We are going to desperately need a strong Commander in Chief in the next several decades!  All of the Islamic Terror groups will not disappear.  The White House may have decided to call them extremists, but they are still terrorists!  They will no doubt continue to evolve from one to another.  The names such as Al Qaeda, ISIL or ISIS really don't make that much difference, they will change as these groups continue to evolve.  They will be with us for a long time to come and we need a leader who is willing to use all means to rid the world of this terrible scourge!
     Experts say that only 10% of Islamic population sympathize with or become extremists.  I don't know how accurate that figure is, but believe me, it is significant.  The Islamic population in America is between 5 to 7 million.  That means, we can count on having somewhere around 500,000 Islamic Extremists/Terrorists who will try to commit murder and mayhem right here!  That's half a million terrorists, larger than our current standing army!  Worldwide, that means there are millions of Islamic Extremists/Terrorists, but we already know that!  So, you can see how important it will be for our next president to be a strong Commander in Chief, not a politician who is concerned with their legacy!

Wednesday, November 4, 2015

Presidential Advisors, "Doctrines," and other stuff.....

     Most of us really don't pay too much attention to Presidential Advisors, those influential figures in the cabinet or White House Staff who have the ear of the President.  Whenever a President makes a decision, it is assumed that the decision was made unilaterally, that it is all up to that one person, the President, to make that decision.  Perhaps that is true in case of a dictator, and it is true to some extent even in democracy, because after all, the final word is coming from that ultimate decision maker.  But all in all, the President, the Prime Minister, or the Chancellor of the country is dependent on his or her advisors to come up with the right answer, and they become the spokesperson for that (hopefully) consensus among the leaders (cabinet members, etc.).
     Among Presidential Advisors, it isn't always the high ranking cabinet member that has the most influence and effect.  Sometimes it is someone at a lower level who convinces their boss to champion their ideas, and their boss convinces the President.  In such a way, sometimes our Presidents don't always get the right or appropriate advice on how to handle a particular situation.  The entire Vietnam War was essentially fought at the direction of our Secretary of Defense at the time, Robert McNamara.  McNamara had tremendous influence on President Johnson and despite his total lack of combat experience, he essentially called the shots on how to conduct the war in Southeast Asia!  Although McNamara served during World War Two in the Army Air Corps, he did not see combat, instead handled statistics for General Lemay, statistics on effectiveness of bombing!  Small wonder we were so obsessed with statistics during Vietnam War!  Of course, McNamara in turn surrounded himself with his advisors, who were just about all civilian "bean counters" and CEO types that not only lacked military experience but disliked the military!
     Vietnam War was the beginning of our "strategy-less" war planning and micro-managing of the war from Washington.  McNamara, who was an automobile industry CEO tried to run the war like he was trying to run GM or Ford!  It was more like he was trying to accomplish a hostile take over of another company rather than winning a war!  Naturally he surrounded himself with assistants and advisors who were also from similar background.  It doesn't take a genius to see that the "management" of the Vietnam War was doomed from the start.  But that was more than a half a century ago, so let's move to a closer period.
     Back in the early 1980s, we had a Secretary of Defense, Caspar Weinberger, who was determined not to repeat what happened during Vietnam.  Unlike McNamara, Weinberger was an Infantry officer who fought in World War Two, so he knew and understood combat.  As President Reagan's Secretary of Defense, Weinberger practiced a doctrine that he created which basically had a few ground rules.  1.  Never go to war without a strategy which has a beginning and an end.  2. Never go to war without overwhelming superiority in force and arms.  3.  Never go to war without a good reason and clear cut goal.  I have paraphrased part of the Weinberger Doctrine, although there never was any formal document that outlined the so-called doctrine.  But that is what Weinberger believed in and advised the President.  In this way, Weinberger felt we would never get involved in another war like Vietnam.
     So, in 1983 when we intervened in Grenada, we went in with overwhelming force, cleared out the Cubans with minimal fuss, rescued the American citizens, and after making sure that the Cubans were gone, left Grenada in short time!  Now the media ridiculed Reagan and his policies, his "Invasion of Grenada," likening it to killing an ant with a sledge hammer!  Too much force, too much man power, so on and so forth went the criticism.  Some in the media even claimed that the rescued American citizens did not need "rescuing."  Those who were rescued, and were grateful, would disagree with that assessment!  But the fact remained that we went in, accomplished the goal, and got out.  No occupation, no lingering guerrilla warfare with insurgents, etc.  Obviously, the Weinberger Doctrine worked!
     General Colin Powell, who served as the National Security Advisor to the President from 1987 to 1989 overlapped with Casper Weinberger who was Secretary of Defense from 1981 to 1987.  Powell was very much impressed with the Weinberger Doctrine.  When George H.W. Bush became president, Colin Powell became one of his trusted advisors, first as the National Security Advisor, then as the Chairman of Joint Chief of Staff.  In 1989 it was decided that something had to be done with Manuel Noriega, the strongman in Panama, he was becoming a real problem. 
     Operation Just Cause was launched with overwhelming force.  There was a precise strategy, from beginning to end with a clear exit strategy.  We went in, got Noriega, and after a very brief stay, got out.  Much like Grenada, it was a clean (as wars go!), quick operation!  It was the Powell Doctrine now.  A year later we went into the Gulf War.  Again, it was with overwhelming force, liberated Kuwait, pushed Saddam back into Baghdad, destroyed his Republican Guard and basically "degraded" his military so he wouldn't be a threat in the region.  Like the Invasion of Grenada and Invasion of Panama, the Gulf war had a precise strategy.  So despite an outcry from some that it was a mistake not to take out Saddam and occupy Iraq, we stopped short.  We had accomplished what we had set out to do, so we left.
     As good as the old Weinberger Doctrine and the newer Powell Doctrines were, there was bound to be an upstart with "new" and "better" ideas.  An Undersecretary of Defense from 2001 to 2005 and Deputy Secretary of Defense from 2005 to 2007, Paul Wolfowitz had his own "doctrine" which he pushed and had his boss, the Secretary of Defense Rumsfeld convinced that he had a great plan.  Wolfowitz Doctrine was better known as "Plan for U.S. World Domination."  He was obsessed with the idea of having the U.S. remain as the sole super power and had all sorts of ideas on how to keep Russia from gaining any influence.  He was also adamant about "taking out" Saddam Hussein and establishing a new regime in Iraq.
     We went into the Second Iraq War basically using Wolfowitz Doctrine.  Unfortunately, the Wolfowitz Doctrine did not provide for complete planning, for aftermath of defeat of Saddam and occupation.  As already mention in an earlier blog, those who championed the Powell Doctrine, Colin Powell himself and General Eric Shinseki were shoved aside.  The Wolfowitz Doctrine was suspiciously similar in approach to war as Robert McNamara's approach to Vietnam War of some half a century earlier! Wolfowitz's boss, Rumsfeld was sold on his underlings ideas and pushed them.  He apparently also convinced other members of the cabinet, for Powell and his "reluctant warrior" policy fell out of favor and we became entangled in Iraq.
     What is amazing to me is that it appears that although the Wolfowitz Doctrine is no longer in favor, we have nothing to replace it.  In short, we have no strategy whatsoever on handling the situations around the world!  Obama's advisors are apparently not concerned with being without a strategy!  Contrary to what Wolfowitz and his followers predicted, Russia did not shrivel up and become a nonentity, instead, it has become a power to contend with, thanks to our bungling and lack of strategy.   In the meantime, rather than "dominating the world" as Wolfowitz planned, we have become a lesser player, especially in the Middle East.
     The President is only as good as the advisors that surround him.  Ronald Reagan was successful because he had the good fortune of having very good advisors.  Let's hope that our next President, whoever it may be, has better advisors than the current President!

Monday, November 2, 2015

"Nation Building"

     I have been harping on the fact that our government does not have a strategy in the Middle East and is constantly committing missteps.  Readers of my blogs are probably sick of hearing the refrain, "we have no strategy," like a broken record!  Unfortunately it is true, and there are many in our government who feel the same way, but their complaint is ignored and they are viewed as "right wingers" or simply anti-Obama!  The fact remains that whether they are "right wingers" or anti-Obama, they are correct, we have no strategy, and doomed to failure unless we do something about it, develop a sound strategy!
     Just when did this "strategy-less" approach to war in the Middle East begin?  It is difficult to pin-point exactly when, but it is possible to get a general idea.  It began with the Second Iraq War and our abandonment of original strategy in Afghanistan after the resounding success of the Special Operations in the early stages of that war.  Initially when we went into Afghanistan, it was with the idea that the Special Operations would lead the Northern Alliance in an unconventional war, with air support, to destroy and oust the Al Qaeda and the Taliban.  Once that was accomplished, we would maintain the Special Forces to continue to train, advise, and lead the various Northern Alliance groups and let them take the lead in defending their turf and also decide how to govern the country.  No doubt there would have been chaos, power struggles, etc. But it would have all been on their "watch" so to speak, and they would have had to work it out on their own.  Our involvement would have been minimal and confined to Special Forces trainers and advisors and economic aide.  However, once we managed to defeat and oust the Al Qaeda and Taliban, our plans changed. 
     First, we got into the business of nation building, selecting our choice for leader of the country, etc.  Second, everybody (in the military) wanted the piece of the action, all the generals and admirals got into the act.  We poured-in army, navy, and marine corps units, built a huge U.S. military presence with accompanying compounds with fast food chain restaurants and all!  Of course we had to twist the arm of NATO to make it appear as if the whole world agreed with what we were doing. This was not part of the original plan.  The original plan was to defeat the enemy then simply help the Afghans maintain status quo in their own way, no matter how disagreeable it may have been to those in Washington.  No nation building, no U.S. military built-up, no NATO and even some former ComBloc countries!  Did you know that there were even troops from Mongolia?! There were too many hands in the cookie jar, too many fingers poking into the pie!  The military, each  branch, wanted the piece of the action while the civilian leaders wanted to get into "nation building!"  So, what initially started out as a pretty straight forward plan (yes, there was a strategy then!) turned into a muddled, multi-pronged misadventure with no end strategy.
     Nation building is something in which we have been a miserable failure, yet we continue to meddle and try to involve ourselves in this arcane and almost mystical practice!  We are no good at it and should stop trying!  For some reason, we keep pointing at Germany and Japan as examples and try to recreate that post World War Two economic miracle.  All those bright minds in Washington seem to think that we can do the same all over the world, have successes with "nation building," making smaller versions of modern Germany and Japan!  What these bright minds are failing to see is that both Germany and Japan were countries with long histories before we defeated them in the war!  They were independent countries long before United States even existed.  Neither Afghanistan or Iraq have had such illustrious histories in modern times.  They may have been ancient civilizations to contend with in the past, but within the last several centuries have been in chaotic state, constantly invaded and occupied by foreign powers.  Neither country has had any experience in democratic form of government, and most of all, they have always been ruled by dictators!  It is unlikely that most people in the region even know the definition of democracy!  Yet, we come in and expect them to start a sort of a mirror image of what Japan and Germany did after the war.  To make matters worst, we back the most crooked and incompetent of all people to run the countries, because they at least know the definition of democracy, although they may not practice it!
     Now we are stuck.  We can just pull out, abandon the whole thing and pretend it never happened.  But I doubt that even the most liberal administration would be willing to do that, so we are stuck.  But then again, who knows, we may just do that!  We did it in Vietnam, so why not in Iraq or Afghanistan?
     No doubt all these bright minds in Washington envisioned a region that would, with our involvement, become free of dictators and establish democratic systems that will eventually spread throughout or, at least establish regimes that would be friendly.  In many instances, I believe we give up the idea of creating a true democracy and hope for a "friendly" regime that would not give us trouble and provide access to oil!
     We need to stop trying to create countries in our image, to our idea of what they should be.  Look at what happened in Vietnam.  We lost all those lives and destroyed so many families on both sides of the ocean trying to create a Vietnam in our image.  All those lives, all that suffering, and for what?  We are no longer at war with Vietnam and seem to be able to get along with them, albeit not bosom buddies, but at least we are not fighting a war!  We have got to stop this nation building business.  We have got to stop thinking that we have the answer to everything, to everyone's problems.

Saturday, October 31, 2015

The Third Iraq War, and the "new" Syrian War

     The first Gulf War was our First Iraq War.  Then the Operation Iraqi Freedom (OIF), which became the Second Iraq War.  President Obama pulled out all U.S. combat troops, not even leaving a residual force to allow for a smoother transition, and Iraq ends up in chaos and a new enemy surfaces, ISIS.  For quite sometime our government refused to acknowledge that it had made a mistake and that Iraq was on the verge of collapse and take over by (at first) a rag-tag, unbelievably cruel terror group that calls itself ISIL or ISIS.  So now (it started with the recent Delta raid on ISIS compound), we are back, engaged in Iraq with boots on the ground.  The so-called surgical air strikes alone did not work.  They cost the tax payers an astronomical amount of money but failed to dislodge ISIS.  Critics maintained from the start that "boots on the ground" were needed and that we should have never pulled out as we did.  Belatedly we are now sending additional Special Operations Units and a Rapid Reaction Force (more than likely Army Rangers or Marines to back up the Special Operation Forces).  We are slowly, once again, building up ground forces in Iraq.
     Meanwhile, in Syria, we have been "leading from behind" all these years, prodding Saudis and other Arab countries as well as Turks to do the fighting and only using our air power.  Obviously it didn't work.  Now (yesterday) President Obama announced that "less than 50" Special Forces advisors and trainers will be sent to Syria within a week to help train and advise Kurds and moderate Arab rebels.  Fifty men?  That's roughly four Special Forces A Detachments (12 men each).  One A Detachment is capable of training and leading a Battalion in battle. Are we going to try to win the war in Syria with four battalions of Kurds and moderate rebels?  Not likely.
     First of all, why so few, and second, why announce the number?  Everything is so politically motivated that it is just sickening.  Obviously by announcing that "less than 50"  Special Forces members will be sent into Syria, the chance of public opposition will be diminished, no doubt that is the reasoning behind the announcement.  However, sending a mere "less than 50" contingent of U.S. soldiers into the lion's den, no matter how well they are trained, is really a very bad move!  Unlike the Special Forces teams in Iraq who will have a U.S. Rapid Reaction Force to help them out if they get into trouble, who will bail out these "less than 50" men if they get into a tight spot?  Syrians?  Iranians, or perhaps Russians?
     In Vietnam the Special Forces learned that they could not rely on none U.S. forces to help them if they got into trouble.  Most U.S. units were too far away from the isolated Special Forces camps, so a Rapid Reaction Force was created by the Special Forces itself, the Mobile Strike Force known as Mike Force made up of Nungs and Montagnards.  They were on call 24/7 to help any beleaguered Special Forces unit.  Apparently the new generation of our leaders have forgotten that lesson.  To allow a small American unit to go deep into enemy territory without any backing is truly a monumental folly!  The whole business that they will only "train and advise" and not be exposed to danger is laughably naïve.  Our very first combat death in Vietnam was a Special Forces soldier killed in an ambush in 1958!  Yes, he was an "advisor and a trainer" sent to advise and train, not fight! Also, you may not be hearing this in the news, but we are suffering casualties in Philippines, a few deaths and wounded out of the 1st Special Forces Group on Okinawa, and these soldiers are trainers and advisors!
     Earlier in Aghanistan and Iraq, the British and Australians tried the approach of training and advising, but not leading the men in combat.  It was a miserable failure by their own admission.  The troops were fine as long as the British or Australian Advisors were in their presence, but once they were on their own, everything went to hell.  We, fortunately, never did that.  Our advisors always stayed with the indigenous troops for that is how we operated in Vietnam!  The Vietnamese use to say, "either protect us and be with us, or leave us alone!"  When we instituted the "Vietnamization" we essentially left them alone!  So, don't you believe the hogwash dealt out by the White House that our advisors and trainers will not participate in combat.  Besides, it is the Special Forces doctrine to not only train and advise, but actually lead the indigenous troops in combat.
     If you look up the definition for strategy in war, it will read something like this:  "Strategy ensures that you get to the right place with right force for the right reasons and the right war."  Of the three Iraq Wars, only the first one, the Gulf War appeared to follow the definition of strategy.  It was never the intention to take out Saddam Hussein or occupy Iraq, so we stopped short of Baghdad, despite heavy criticism from some quarters, and ended the war.  Unfortunately, our leaders today are unfamiliar with the definition, for we have no strategy!  That has been the criticism and complaint about this administration and its policies or none policies in the Middle East - No Strategy!
     An ancient Chinese warrior/philosopher, Sun Tzu, said that "strategy without tactics is a slow road to victory, but tactics without strategy is noise before defeat!"  We have plenty of tactics, great tactics.  That is how we were able to carry off that raid on the ISIS compound with such success.  Every time our ground troops go to battle we employ sound tactics, but unfortunately, we have no strategy!  To paraphrase from Sun Tzu's book, The Art of War, "those without strategy cannot but be defeated!"
     The worst possible way to engage in a war is to "lead from behind."  We have been "leading from behind" in Syria, and Libya.  Look where it has gotten us!  Syria is a mess and now Russia and Iran appear to be the major "stockholders" in the region!  Libya caused the death of our Ambassador and four others, a shameful occurrence.  We made threats about crossing the "thin red line" which was crossed numerous times and we did nothing.  Putin saw that he could push his way into just about anything without fear of our intervention.  He was right.  So now, after Syria had reached a point where "moderate" rebels are about to be wiped out by Russia's indiscriminate bombing (Russian "smart" bombs are considered accurate when they strike within a block!) and Iranian ground forces, we are going to send "less than 50" Special Forces soldiers with no back up such as a Rapid Reaction Force?  Talk about no strategy! 
     This latest move is doomed before it has started, unless there will be an announcement shortly that additional forces will be deployed to Syria.  But I wouldn't hold my breath.  We have a White House that is micromanaging the wars in the Middle East.  This has happened before, under Jimmy Carter.  What we have is a bunch of civilians with no military or combat experience who think they know better than the generals in the Pentagon and are micromanaging the whole thing.  They see wars as computer games, rely too heavily on technology, drones, etc.  They believe that the concept of boots on the ground is outdated, old fashioned, after all, this is the 21st Century!  They think that boots on the ground means only Special Operations, which they can watch on monitors in the White House Situation Room like a video game. They hate to admit that they are wrong, so right now they are viewing the situation as a temporary set back and grudgingly agreed to putting boots on the ground....without an overall strategy!

Wednesday, October 28, 2015

"Direct Action" and Kurds

     With the recent death of Army Master Sergeant Joshua Wheeler in Iraq during a raid on an ISIS compound, our government has created a new definition for combat.  It is not combat anymore, it is now the politically correct term, "direct action."  It seems that Master Sergeant Wheeler did not die as a result of ground combat in which he participated with the peshmerga commando unit, but rather he was killed as a result of "direct action." 
     Now, you must admit that "direct action" sounds a lot less dangerous or menacing than "hostile" action, or god forbid, "combat!"  We are very PC.  Since President Obama announced that we will no longer have any combat troops in Iraq, we no longer participate in combat.  We are there to advise and train, and observe.  Only an air war will be conducted against ISIS.  Ground combat?  Perish the thought!  Remember the words of Obama's speech at Fort Bragg after he announced our withdrawal of combat troops from Iraq?  He said, "I am bringing this war to a close!  After more than a decade, I am ending this war and no American life will be put in harms way any more!  We will have only a small contingent of advisors and trainers."  Ambitious words they were! It also gave ISIS and Al Qaeda a clear "green light" to launch and escalate their campaigns in Iraq.
     You might recall my earlier blogs on this subject when I said that there is no way that the so-called U.S. "advisors and trainers" will stay out of combat if they are to train, advise, and lead the Iraqi forces.  Yet, our leaders insisted that no U.S. soldier will be put in harms way any more.  Now, after Wheeler's death, the Secretary of Defense refers to his death as a result of "direct action!"  At the same time, it is interesting to note how the fact that the peshmerga's were accompanied by Delta was sort of skipped over.  Delta, incidentally, as everyone knows, is not an advisory or training unit, nor is it a defensive unit!  It is strictly an offensive arm of the Special Operations, used specifically to conduct raids and other offensive operations.  But I guess in this case Delta was there as an observer.  Incidentally, depending on the nature of the mission, the degree of classification, deaths with Delta are not necessarily released to the public.  So a Delta operator could be killed in a highly classified mission and his death will not be made public.  That is standard procedure for units such as Delta.
     Nowadays it is hard to believe anything that our government says about our activities in the Middle East or elsewhere for that matter.  Everything is obfuscated, I'd hate to think what else we are being told besides that combat is now "direct action,"  Our leaders have been known to play a bit loose with facts in the past, but it seems that it has now reached the point of being an art form, we really don't know what actually is taking place!
     The other side of this whole situation in Iraq is our continual dependence on the Kurds and the peshmergas.  As I have said repeatedly in earlier blogs, they are the only ones doing any fighting!  The Kurds are the only ones that we can depend on, yet, we have betrayed them twice before and have betrayed them for the third time recently.  However, the Kurds have no choice but to ally with us, we are the only ones that at least provide them with arms!
     The most recent betrayal of Kurds took place when we made Turkey our ally in our fight against ISIS.  The Turks are fighting ISIS, sort of, but they are also fighting Kurds!  The Turks are paranoid about having Kurds gain independence and, therefore, have their own sovereign territory, Kurdistan.  If Kurdistan becomes an independent state, it will take up a good portion of Turkish real estate!  So, the Turks are probably fighting Kurds with more enthusiasm than they are fighting ISIS!  What are we going to do with Kurds when we ultimately pull out of that region, which we will, sooner or later!  It would be another travesty, a human tragedy if we do abandon them as we abandoned the Montagnards and the Nungs in Vietnam!
     One small way that we can try to help the Kurds before everything falls apart again is to take on Kurdish refugees.  Among the refugees that are escaping Syria and landing in Greece and other Balkan countries are Kurds.  Recently one of our intelligence organizations said that there is no way that we can vet all the refugees that we will be taking in!  There are some that fear there will be ISIS or Al Qaeda members in the midst of these refugees, no doubt that will be the case.  One way to lower that possibility is to take Kurds!  There are no known ISIS or Al Qaeda members that are of Kurdish origin!  We owe the Kurds, so why not take all of the Kurdish refugees?  Seems to me a logical solution.
     I fear for Kurds.  I fear that the same thing will happen to them that happened to those unfortunate people who blindly and loyally fought for us in Vietnam.  Fortunately for the Kurds, they are a much larger group of people than Nungs (who were a very tiny minority) and the Montagnards (who are also relatively small in numbers).  The Kurds are a sizable population that is spread across Turkey, Syria, Iraq and Iran.  They are also found in small pockets in Armenia and other surrounding countries.  So, although they have been persecuted historically for centuries and will probably continue to be persecuted, unless they gain independence, but they will survive for better or worse.
     As long as we are in that part of the world engaged in war against ISIS, Al Qaeda, or any other such Islamic Terror groups, we will rely on the Kurds to be our allies.  They are the only ones that we can count on when the chips are down, as we have discovered after more than a decade of war in Iraq, Afghanistan, and now Syria (indirectly, that is!). We now also have a new name for combat, a more PC term, "direct action."  I wonder what the definition of "indirect action" would be in this case?

Friday, October 23, 2015

State Department - How it works, or doesn't!

     The State Department building, an imposing structure, is located in the part of Washington that is known as the Foggy Bottom. The Metro Station closest to the State Department is called the Foggy Bottom, and naturally, the organization took on that nick-name.  Pentagon may be known as the "puzzle palace," but the State Department is known as the "foggy bottom," for more reasons than its location!  There are, however, annexes scattered throughout Washington area as well, so the State Department is literally all over Washington area.
     Most people, other than those working for the State Department, do not really know how it is organized and how it really functions or doesn't function.  Everyone is aware that U.S. government civilian employees working for various departments and agencies are categorized as General Schedule or GS (other than the Post Office).  The ranking system goes from the low of GS-1 (with officer grading from GS-7) to the high of GS-15, which is equivalent to the military 0-6 Colonel (Army, Air Force, Marines) or Captain in the Navy.  Above GS-15 (there used to be GS 16 through 18, but not any more) there is now the Senior Executive Service, the SES which is equivalent to General/Flag Officer rank.  In the State Department, however, there are actually two categories of career employees, the GS employees and the FS or the Foreign Service.  The FS ranking system goes in the opposite direction from GS, the lower the number, the higher the grade, so an FS-1 would be like the GS-15.  After FS-1, there is the Senior Foreign Service, the SFS, which is like the SES or General/Flag Officer.
     The difference is that the GS employees are stationed in Washington DC or elsewhere within the U.S., domestically, whereas the FS employees, as their name implies, are required to serve abroad at posts around the world.  The third none career category are the political appointees, those that gained their positions through political appointment (connections!).  The vast majority of employees in the State Department building in Washington and offices around the U.S. are GS type employees.  However, the FS employees are encouraged to return to the U.S. and serve at least a tour (2, 3 or 4 years) to keep them familiar with how things work back home and also to prevent some from going "native" abroad!  GS employees in turn are encouraged to take what is known as an "excursion tour" overseas and work at a post, usually in Consular or Administrative areas, but occasionally in other fields as well, so they will know what it is like to be at the other end!  However, for the GS employees it is usually just a one shot deal, whereas the FS employees spend their entire government service careers abroad with occasional break in Washington.
     Within the structure of the FS system, there are two distinct categories, the FO and the FP.  The FO stands for the Foreign Service Officers.  This is the traditional Foreign Service diplomatic officers career path.  FSOs as they are known, enter the service by taking the rather difficult Foreign Service Exam that is offered annually, and generally speaking, you have to be a college graduate.  The FP stands for Foreign Service Professional and they could be in any number of fields everything from communications, general services, medical, etc.  FPs do not enter the Foreign Service through the same process.  To reach the highest positions in the Foreign Service, you have to be in the FO category.
     The State Department is the recipient and provider of information on foreign affairs matters of our government since the days of Ben Franklin who was our first diplomat.  It is the State Department that gathers and provides information to the White House about foreign politics, economy, military and intelligence.  Of course information on military and intelligence is also provided separately by Pentagon's DIA and CIA as well.  All information that is gathered abroad goes to the State Department, to various offices and country desks (country specific offices).  The important information goes directly to the Operations Center where the information is digested and provided in Secretary of State's briefing each morning.  The Operation Center is manned by FSOs and all key positions in various offices and desks are manned by FSOs doing their stateside tours.  All matters concerning security are directed to the Diplomatic Security Office and the Operations Center as well.  So, matters concerning security at posts abroad are included in Secretary's briefing each morning. 
     In the past, prior to the 1980s when attacks on our diplomatic missions abroad escalated, an overzealous editor in the Operations Center might have, on occasion, left out information about security concerns at some small post abroad.  But that was not the case after the various attacks on our missions in the 1980s took place.  All requests or reports about security of our posts abroad was and is included in the Secretary's morning briefing paper.  It is inconceivable that if there were over 60 requests for security assistance from Benghazi, that the Secretary was unaware of it!  If all 60 plus requests were ignored and left out of the Secretary's briefings, then someone in the Operations Center was grossly negligent and should be in prison!
     So, there's the brief and somewhat inadequate run down on State Department and how information is disseminated in the system.  Information comes in from abroad, and disseminated to various offices according to the tags that were provided on the message.  Important information and information concerning security, regardless of how it was tagged, goes to the Operations Center.  The Operations Center digests all the incoming information and provides a briefing memo for the Secretary of State each morning....sort of a, "this is what happened around the world while you were sleeping" kind of a memo.  As I said, if all those requests for help from Benghazi were indeed left out of the Secretary's briefings, then someone was indeed was seriously, criminally negligent.  It wouldn't be all that difficult to find who was responsible.  Each shift in the Operations Center has editors and the Supervising Officer of the shift.  The Operations Center is open 24/7 so there are several shifts.  It would be easy enough to find the dates of the requests on who was on the shift.  Besides, copies of the Secretary's briefs should be available, unless they were all destroyed!
     Watching this last "Benghazi Hearing" taking place, I was appalled at the committees lack of understanding of how the State Department works, and therefore, their inability to ask the proper questions.  At the same time, I was appalled that Hillary was able to get away by simply answering that she did not know of 60 plus requests for increased security from Benghazi, that she left that up to the "experts."  It is one thing to leave the job of security to the experts, nobody expects the Secretary to handle everything personally, but it is another thing to say that you were totally unaware of the 60 plus requests for help!  There is something terribly wrong with the system if that is indeed the case.  The State Department is far from being perfect and it has made many mistakes in the past, but this bit about not knowing, not being informed, is hard to swallow.

Wednesday, October 21, 2015

U.S. - Israel Relations

     There is no doubt that the single most important country to the United States in the Middle East is Israel.  Without Israel we have no country in the region that we can truly rely on.  Yes we have other "friends" in the region, those that we have "bought" with military assistance and favorable trade agreements, those that supply us with oil to supplement our own domestic production.  But these are "fair weather" friends.  I hate to say this, but they would turn on us on a dime.  Despite our "friendly" relations with these countries now, we do have some major philosophical differences, namely in religion and our differing views on life in general!  However, as long as they supply us with oil and buy our military equipment, we remain "friends." 
     That is not the case with Israel.  Israel is much closer to us than we would like to admit.  Yes, we are predominantly a Christian nation (for now!) and Israel's national religion is Judaism.  But, we seem to possess many of the same beliefs and be in tune for most things in life.  In short, we are a lot like the Israelis and they are like us in many ways as well!  However, there are some major differences, mainly due to the different situations that we live under.  Israel is under constant state of war.  Even if there isn't an actual war taking place, there are terror attacks and killings taking place constantly.  They live in a state of war and they, of all people, know their neighbors (Islamic nations) better than anyone else!  They have to, because all of those countries surrounding Israel have openly sworn to destroy Israel, wipe it off the face of the earth!
     Of course, there is no denying that Israel receives a huge amount of assistance, both economic and military, from us and it is arguable whether they could survive as a country without our help.  But it works both ways.  We are not giving Israel all that help just out of the goodness of our hearts, out of Christian charity, we give them aide in return for having their staunch support in the region.
     The Israeli intelligence is vital to us.  They have better access and better knowledge of their Arab neighbors than we could ever hope to have.  It is because of Israel's superior intelligence and better disciplined military force that Israel is able to repeatedly defeat much larger Arab enemies time and time again.  We have much to learn from Israel if we are to navigate successfully through Middle Eastern intrigues and politics and hope to be a major player in the region.  We sought Israeli advice before the first Gulf War, but recently appear to have been ignoring their advice.
     Our relationship with Israel have soured considerably in the last several years.  Even prior to our recent nuclear deal with Iran, things were beginning to get very strained.  It appeared to Israel (rightly or not) that we were favoring Arab nations on several issues that involved Arab-Israeli relations.  There were even some murmurings from some that this administration was a sympathizer of Islam, especially after the first Iftar dinner at the White House!  The Israelis questioned, "why is there now an annual Iftar dinner?"  A good question.  In case you are unfamiliar, Iftar is a dinner celebration that is held at the end of Ramadan, the Islamic fasting period. Whatever the case, Iftar or no Iftar, the Iran Nuclear Deal really caused some major cracks to appear.
     Israel's eloquent Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, appealed before our congress and before his own nation, arguing against the Iran Nuclear Deal.  He called it "the worst deal in history!"  Our liberal media "poo-pooed" his words, called him a "hawk," a paranoid anti-Arab, and that he was only looking out for Israel.  Some even said that it was nothing but a re-election ploy, that once he was re-elected, he would back off and agree with the nuclear deal.  Well, he was re-elected and he hasn't backed-off.  He has toned down his rhetoric somewhat, because things were getting too heated, but he is every bit against it as he was before.  Naturally, he has the best interest of Israel, after all he is the Prime Minister of Israel!  I would be very suspicious of a U.S President who does not have the interest of the U.S. first!  But just because he is a patriot doesn't mean what he says does not make sense or does not apply to us.  He is, by far, the most experienced of all the players involved in international affairs if you compare him with Obama, Biden, Kerry, and any of the others involved in pushing and negotiating the Iran Nuclear Deal.
     Benjamin Netanyahu was born in Tel Aviv of intellectual parents.  His father was a history professor and his mother a scientist.  He had three brothers, one older (Jonathan) and two younger.  All brothers served in the Israeli Defense Force, all in the famous Sayaret Matkal, the Israeli Special Forces.  Jonathan, the oldest, was a commander of Sayaret Matkal and died a hero in the famous Raid on Entebbe to rescue Israeli hostages from Arab terrorists.  All brothers were highly educated.  Benjamin received a Bachelors in Architecture and a Masters in Management from MIT.  He went on to work on his Ph.D. in Political Science at Harvard, but his studies were interrupted when his older brother Jonathan was killed in Entebbe, so he returned to Israel.
     He, like all his brothers served with Israeli Special Forces, in two wars, the 1967-70 War of Attrition and the 1973 Yom Kippur War.  He was wounded several times and received medals for heroism.  He knows what war is all about.  This is what he said recently about his time with Sayaret Matkal:  "I have great respect for the unit. This is a unit that changes the reality of our lives even though its actions are a secret.  Although it is a small unit, it influences all branches of the military...My service in the unit strengthened my understanding of the risks involved behind approving operations and the risks that the fighters are taking on.  It is tangible, not theoretical for me."  The key is the last sentence.  War and its effects are tangible to him, not theoretical!  It seems to many of our leaders, war is theoretical, like some computer game!
     Netanyahu's political experience in international relations are equally impressive.  He served as Israel's Foreign Minister from 2002 to 2003 and again from 2012 to 2013.  He was Israel's Prime Minister the first time from 1996 to 1999, then 2009 to 2015, re-elected in 2015 to present.  He also served in a myriad of ministerial positions in Israeli government and was Israel's Deputy Chief of Mission to their embassy in Washington and later Israel's Ambassador to the United Nations.  So, this is a man who has intimate knowledge of world politics, especially when it comes to dealing with his Arab neighbors.  Of course he is disliked by the Arabs, that is because he knows them so well!  Yet, our leaders, who have miniscule experience compared to his when dealing with Arabs, ignore his words and proceed full steam ahead like bulls in a china shop!  Now, if that isn't arrogance, I guess it is just plain stupidity!  None of our leaders have even a smidgen of knowledge of how the Islamic mind works.  We have never been able to decipher the Middle Eastern mind, especially that of Iran with whom we have had problems since 1979!  Israel, on the other hand, has intimate knowledge of Iranian psyche, their way of thinking and doing things.  That is because before the fall of Shah in 1979, Israel was heavily involved in Iran in various industrial and military projects and many Israelis spent years living and working with Iranians!
     So now we have become somewhat estranged with Israel.  It is quite apparent by facial expressions and body languages of both Obama and Netanyahu that neither one cares for the other, only Putin possibly can generate a more negative reaction from Obama and visa versa!  It is a pity, because at this time we desperately need all the help we can get in dealing with our problems in the Middle East.  Yes, Israel is hated by all the Arabs, therefore, we need to walk a fine line if we want the Arab oil!  But we've done it before, without causing a rift, why can't we do it now?  Unless the current leadership does not want to, and thinks it knows all there is to know about the Middle East.  Israel is still our best source of information and intelligence on Middle East, we can't afford to break that tie if we want to remain a major player in the region.
     Benjamin Netanyahu, like many other Israelis, is unique in his knowledge of the Arabs.  He has fought them in wars and he deals with them daily on the political scene.  He knows Arabs like no one in our administration could possibly know.  It is mind boggling to me why we don't take advantage of this resource and mine the knowledge that he has.  We don't need to agree with him, but we sure could use his knowledge!